User talk:Anonymous31415927: Difference between revisions

From Rosetta Code
Content added Content deleted
(Blanked the page)
Line 1: Line 1:
== 99 problematic edits ==

About the page "99 bottles of beer", py language, first solution:

1. You targeted my simple version as copied by http://www.99-bottles-of-beer.net/language-python-573.html . And yes, I first wrote a simple version myself, I saw the www.99-bottles-of-beer.net version and I modified it, clearly inspired. I also explicitly linked the original code. But the code is '''different'''. I simply copied the '''concept''' of not repeating "bottles of beer on the wall", but to use it in a variable.

2. You continue to rename my version. Now is "Python 2, short version". Well:

:a. "Python 2" is useless and inexact. It's useless because I wrote the target version before the code. It's not exact because it works also for Python 3 (I tested it on Python 3.9 alpha... :-D).
:b. You also changed the target version. I wrote "2.6+" and you removed the plus. Why? If I write "2.6+", it means that it works for Python 2.6 and any subsequent version (currently).
:c. The name I would give to my code is "(Currently) the simplest version". Probably is also the shorter, but who cares. I think it's the simplest because it does not manage special cases of 0 and 1, as allowed in the task. It simply do one string assignment, a loop and a print inside the loop. Stop. More simple than that can only be printing the entire song :-D

I kindly hope you agree and I can modify the solution without another counter-edit.

PS: Happy New Year in retard.

[[User:Marco_Sulla|Marco Sulla]] - [[User_talk:Marco_Sulla|talk]] - [https://github.com/Marco-Sulla GitHub] 23:23, 26 January 2020 (UTC)

Revision as of 23:23, 26 January 2020

99 problematic edits

About the page "99 bottles of beer", py language, first solution:

1. You targeted my simple version as copied by http://www.99-bottles-of-beer.net/language-python-573.html . And yes, I first wrote a simple version myself, I saw the www.99-bottles-of-beer.net version and I modified it, clearly inspired. I also explicitly linked the original code. But the code is different. I simply copied the concept of not repeating "bottles of beer on the wall", but to use it in a variable.

2. You continue to rename my version. Now is "Python 2, short version". Well:

a. "Python 2" is useless and inexact. It's useless because I wrote the target version before the code. It's not exact because it works also for Python 3 (I tested it on Python 3.9 alpha... :-D).
b. You also changed the target version. I wrote "2.6+" and you removed the plus. Why? If I write "2.6+", it means that it works for Python 2.6 and any subsequent version (currently).
c. The name I would give to my code is "(Currently) the simplest version". Probably is also the shorter, but who cares. I think it's the simplest because it does not manage special cases of 0 and 1, as allowed in the task. It simply do one string assignment, a loop and a print inside the loop. Stop. More simple than that can only be printing the entire song :-D

I kindly hope you agree and I can modify the solution without another counter-edit.

PS: Happy New Year in retard.

Marco Sulla - talk - GitHub 23:23, 26 January 2020 (UTC)